Linux Don’t Need No Stinkin’ ZFS: BTRFS Intro & Benchmarks

ZFS may be locked into the Solaris operating system but "Butter FS" is on the horizon and it's boasting more features and better performance.

Linux is a fun project to watch because you get to see this living and breathing piece of software change and evolve.

Recently, Linux has been undergoing something of a revolution with a respect to file systems. There are a number of projects including ext4 (See ext4 File System: Introduction and Benchmarks), squashfs, nilfs which have made it into the kernel, and tux3, which hasn’t made it into the kernel yet but is under heavy development.

And perhaps most importantly, btrfs. Btrfs holds the promise of giving Linux many enterprise class file system features similar to ZFS (See Solving Common Administration Problems with ZFS and ZFS on FUSE) but with even more features and better performance. In fact, many Linux experts think that btrfs is one of the keys to the future of Linux. While btrfs is not quite ready to be your only file system, it is in the kernel ready for testing and is still undergoing very heavy development.

In this article we will introduce the key features of btrfs find out how it compares to existing file systems. We will also test it using iozone, with the understanding that it’s still in development so performance will likely change over time.

Introduction to btrfs

Btrfs, sometimes called “Butter FS”, is a new file system for Linux that has a wealth of features users have been wanting for some time. Chris Mason, who works at Oracle, started the project and Oracle has released the project under the GPL license so anyone can work on it. Btrfs has a gained a very large following within the Linux community and has whipped up a good deal of buzz. Some of the features of btrfs that have led to this buzz are:


  • Copy on Write
  • Extents (see article about ext4)
  • Space efficient packing of small files (file systems have needed this for a long time)
  • Space efficient indexed directories
  • Dynamic inode allocation
  • Writable snapshots
  • Snapshots of snapshots
  • Subvolumes (separate internal filesystem roots)
  • Object level mirroring and striping
  • Checksums on data and metadata
  • Compression
  • Integrated multiple device support, with several RAID algorithms
  • Online filesystem check and defragmentation
  • Very fast offline filesystem check
  • Efficient incremental backup and File System mirroring

You can tell from the list of features that btrfs is a very ambitious project with a load of features (got to love that).

One of the most immediate questions one would have about btrfs is, “how does it compare to ZFS?” That’s a great question. There is a pretty good blog posting that attempts to impartially compare btrfs and ZFS. While the comparison is quite long, a quick summary of the comparison is below:

Feature
ZFS
BTRFS
Copy on Write yes yes
Snapshots yes yes
Snapshots of snapshots ? yes
Performance degradation at near 98-100% disk usage yes Most likely yes
Block level compression yes Currently a mount option
Disk encryption Being developed Planned but not currently in kernel. Encryptfs could be an option
Online resizing no (being worked on) yes
Online defragmentation no (being being worked on as part of other projects) yes
Write checksums yes yes
Built-in RAID yes (0,1,10, 5 with fixes for write hole (raidz), and some variant of 6 called raidz) yes (0, 1, 10)
ACL yes yes
Direct IO yes Writes yes. Reads No – Planned
Quotas yes yes

Next: Feature Breakdown

Comments on "Linux Don’t Need No Stinkin’ ZFS: BTRFS Intro & Benchmarks"

waddles

Jeff – you didn’t mention what type of disks you used for benchmarking, but your results sure look like you’re hitting the practical bandwidth limits of SATA-150. I sure would like to see a benchmark on InfiniBand 12x.

Also, what happened to comparing Ext3/Ext4 on RAID?

Reply
samrawlins

Jeff, great article! Very informative summaries of the new features. I hope you write a follow-up in a few months (years?) when BTRFS is declared stable. What type of disk(s) are you using?

I do take issue with your claims regarding compression:

When compression was turned on the performance increased by a large amount. The write and rewrite performance almost doubles and the read and reread performance increases by about 30%.

Write performance enhancements vary greatly. The Write performance increase via compression should be split into three sets of data: When using “nodatacow” and “nodatasum”, the difference is minimal. Otherwise, when using any RAID, performance increases by about 40% (50 MB/s to 70 MB/s in most tests). Otherwise (“Standard” or “-m single” options), performance more than doubles (30 MB/s to 70 MB/s).

Read performance enhancements do not vary greatly, but are also certainly not 30% when using compression. There is a

Reply
jimmershere

Excellent article! I’m glad to see this kind of technology in the OpenSource world!

I do need to point out some incorrect entries in the BTRFS vs. ZFS comparison chart, however. specifically:

ZFS can online resize.
ZFS can repair/check/defrag while online. (scrub)
ZFS can take a snapshot of a snapshot

That being said, BTRFS still sounds like an exciting addition to Linux and I can’t wait to test it out.

Reply
craig73

It would have been useful to have CPU usage statistics for all these tests to identify the cost of compression. I would have expected that the compression level/algorithm be selected to increase IO bandwidth at a slight cost to CPU overhead, but the lack of CPU numbers makes it difficult to evaluate how much of a cost that 30% came at.

[I'm also curious how tunable this is, based on larger CPUs and larger caches, or specific workloads]

Reply
craig73

(BTW – I recognize the compression of zero’s makes the compression numbers meaningless)

Reply
laytonjb

Yep – I’m hitting the bandwidth limit pretty quickly. It’s a pretty old machine. I’m trying to get the family funding agency to fund my proposal for a new machine. :) No word yet but I think the funding agency is waiting for their stimulus package to arrive.

Are you looking for a benchmark of a system with a number of drives and btrfs exporting it over NFS/RDMA over IB?

Reply
laytonjb

I’m not sure I follow you? Are you saying the read performance can vary by a great deal so 30% may be in the noise?

I didn’t run the tests a number of times and compute the average or examine the standard deviation in a systematic manner. But I did run them several times to get a feel for the results. The numbers I reported are right around the average but that is by eyeball :)

BTW – I’m not sure when they will declare Btrfs stable. I’m guessing early 2010. I talked to Chris but didn’t ask that question. They are still doing some fairly heavy lifting in the code base. I think the on-disk format is fixed but they could change it one more time (it’s still marked as “experimental” :) ).

Did I capture your questions correctly or am I missing something?

Thanks!

Reply
laytonjb

Thanks for the comments. Can you point to an on-line source for the ZFS features? I’ve been looking for some time for a comprehensive list of ZFS features without luck.

Thanks!

Reply
laytonjb

You’re absolutely correct but I didn’t track the CPU usage during the run :( Bonnie++ might be an easier way to get this information.

I have an interview with Chris Mason that will be appearing soon. He pointed out that the crc32 computations used in the compression can now be done in hardware with Nehalem. I hope to have a Nehalem system soon and I will definitely test this out.

If you want me to repost the testing and to add more tests, let the editor know :)

Thanks!

Reply
sysadmn

One pretty good intro to ZFS is here: http://opensolaris.org/os/community/zfs/whatis/

It’s a glorified bullet list with a brief description of what each feature means.

For example, one could quibble on the “snapshot of snapshots” feature:

ZFS backup and restore are powered by snapshots. Any snapshot can generate a full backup, and any pair of snapshots can generate an incremental backup. Incremental backups are so efficient that they can be used for remote replication — e.g. to transmit an incremental update every 10 seconds.

It also appears you’ve left some of the ZFS advantages out of the table – I’d encourage your readers to see the original blog posting. I don’t know if this is in BTRFS, but it’s a lifesaver:

ZFS provides unlimited constant-time snapshots and clones. A snapshot is a read-only point-in-time copy of a filesystem, while a clone is a writable copy of a snapshot. Clones provide an extremely space-efficient way to store many copies of mostly-shared data such as workspaces, software installations, and diskless clients.

Reply
mark_w

I am very glad to see this comparison, but I would like to make a few comments.

- the title/summary is poor. The comment “Linux don’t need no stinkin’ ZFS…“Butter FS” is on the horizon and it’s boasting more features and better performance” is misleading.

According to your summary table, you have one area in which BTRFS can be considered more featured than ZFS (snapshots of snapshots). Considering that you haven’t even discussed clones (which maybe do the same thing or more) and that ZFS is not only a filesystem but it, and its utilities, integrate the LVM features and it has, right now, a wide selection of RAID modes that are actually functioning and it does ‘automagic’ adaptation to volumes of differing performance values, this seems to be a claim that you get nowhere near justifying. Maybe, eventually, it will be true, but the current version doesn’t have the features and there is little evidence that ‘first stable release’ will either.

(Sorry, I’m not trying to say that BTRFS is ‘bad’, just that you are accidentally overclaiming; my guess would be that you haven’t read much on ZFS and all of its features. I think if you had, you would have realised that BTRFS on its own or in its first stable release isn’t going to do it. BTRFS plus on the fly compression, plus a revised MD, plus LVM may well, though, but I’m expecting to wait a bit for all of those to work ideally together.)

- the title leads you to believe that BTRFS will be shown to have a better performance than ZFS. The actual comparison is between BTRFS and ext filesystems with various configurations.

- one of the clever features of ZFS is protection against silent data corruption. This may not be vital to me now, but as filesystem sizes increase…a colleague deals with the situation in which a research project grabs nearly 1G of data every day and they have data going back over 5 years (and they intend to keep capturing data for another 50+ years). As he says “how do I ensure that the data that we read is the data that we wrote?”, and its a good question. ZFS is good in that, admittedly obscure, situation, but I’m not sure whether BTRFS will be.

- You make (indirectly) the very good point that with the more advanced filesystems, benchmarking performance can be rather sensitive to set-up options. I am very glad that you did that testing and hope that you can do more thorough testing as we get closer to a version 1.0 release. I am not sure that I can help you with your funding submission, though…

It is also the case that the results that you get are heavily dependant on what you measure, so the more different tests you do, the better.

- another clever feature of ZFS (sorry about sounding like sounding like a stuck record, but I am impressed by ZFS and would love to be as impressed by BTRFS) is that you can make an array incorporating SSDs and hard disks and have the system automagically sort out the usage of the various storage types to give an agregate high performance, low-cost-per-TB, array. In a commercial setting this is probably one of the biggest advantages that ZFS has over earlier technology. I’m sure that I don’t have to use the ‘O’ word here, but this is a vital advantage that Sun has, and I’m expecting to see some interesting work on optimising this system, in particular for database accesses, soon.

(BTW, this is so effective that a hybrid array, as used in Amber Road, can be so effective that comparing a hybrid array of SSDs and slow hard disks can be faster, cheaper and much more power efficient than one using the usual enterprise class SAS disks, so this can be an interesting solution, in enterprise apps)

If you wish to know more about ZFS, you can do worse than read Sun’s whitepapers on the subject; search on “sun zfs discovery day” to get more info; the presentation is very readable. (I’m not, btw, suggesting that this is an unbiased comparison of ZFS to anything else; its a description of the features and how-to-use.)

Reply
smino

I was going to say your trasnfer speeds are slow, as I get 70MB/s trasnfer files over ethernet Gige from XP to Unraid cache drive (csche meaning single drive unprotected no raid) which uses rieserFS. The drives are use are two 500GB Seagte 7200.12 and seagate 1.5TB 7200.11. I am sure the performance would be better trasnfering from drive to drive and not over ethernet. I am pretty close to hitting the Ethernet practical limit. Of course this is with my aqntivirus running and zone alarm pro, and streaming a movie from the same box.

If anyone gets a chance to test the brts performance on a fast system with those seagate drives above, please let me know.
I chose those drives because they are as fast at the veloraptor 10K drives, only more storage and cheaper!
Sly.

Reply
softweyr

One (of the many) mis-understood features of ZFS is how the file metadata works. In most existing filesystems that support arbitrary metadata, the metadata space is limited and essentially allows key/data pairs to be associated with the file. In ZFS, the metadata for each filesystem object is another entire filesystem rooted at the containing file. ZFS is, in essence, a 3D filesystem. Consider Apple’s application bundles, currently implemented as a directory that the Finder application recognizes and displays specially. Using ZFS, the application file could be the icon file for the application, all of the component files, including executables, libraries, localization packs, and other app resources, would be stored in the file metadata. To the outside world, the bundle truly appears as a single file.

ZFS has it’s warts, for instance that storage of small files is quite inefficient, but actually besting it is going to be a long, hard slog. I suspect the big commercial Linux distributions will iron out the licensing issues somehow and including ZFS in their distributions in the next year. Linux is too big a business to be driven by the religious zealots anymore.

Reply
bezya01

Will BTRFS have the option to sync to file system copies over
the network (WAN as well…)?
I believe ZFS has such an option and Linux DRBD allows this as
well on the device level.

Yours,

Jack.

http://itprofessional-mastermind.com/blog

Reply
rogerdpack

no speed comparisons with zfs?

Reply
stoatwblr

2-and-a-bit years on and ZFS is still chugging along nicely as a working, robust filesystem (and yes, it _does_ have snapshots of snapshots) which I’ve found impossible to break.

Meantime, Btrfs has again trashed itself on my systems given scenarios as simple as power failure.

That’s without even going into the joy of ZFS having working ssd read and write caching out front which substantially boosts performance while keeping the robustness (even 64Gb is more than adequate for a 10TB installation I use for testing)

If there’s any way of reconciling CDDL and GPL then the best way forward would be to combine forces. BTRFS has a lot of nice ideas but ZFS has them too and it has the advantage of a decade’s worth of actual real world deployment experience to draw on.

Less infighting among OSS devs, please.

Reply

I like the helpful info you supply on your articles. I will bookmark your weblog and test again here regularly. I am rather sure I will learn a lot of new stuff right here! Best of luck for the next!

Reply

thank you for share!

Reply

thank you for share!

Reply

ADlXqM sfniwfumhdfb, [url=http://zinhdqbcoowg.com/]zinhdqbcoowg[/url], [link=http://ottqymguefje.com/]ottqymguefje[/link], http://wfymyzusaqym.com/

Reply

If you go with a company which is not honest, you might end up in the much worse financial
state than you commenced with miley cyrus concert tickets 2014 however, the borrower
has to settle the total amount on time, in order to boost his credit history, that can get affected adversely
in the case of defaults.

Reply

I just want to mention I am just very new to blogs and honestly savored you’re web page. Most likely I’m likely to bookmark your blog post . You definitely come with great article content. Many thanks for revealing your blog site.

Reply

Buy Online Cipro 500mg Side Effects Mayo Clinic Seroquel Xr

Reply

Buy Ultram Without Using A Script Omeprazole Prilosec Side Effects Proton Pump Inhibitors

Reply

Protonix Generic Buy Benadryl Common Cold Side Effects

Reply

Buy Singulair Online Advice No Withdrawal From Tramadol Respiratory Depression

Reply

Pak Buy Zithromax Lamictal Side Effects Sweating Skin Rashes

Reply

Xr Pics Buy Xanax Tramadol Products Opiate Withdrawal

Reply

Fosamax Generic Buy Methotrexate Parenteral Side Effects

Reply

No Prescription Buy Plavix Mmorpg Avapro Irbesartan Side Effects Drug Information

Reply

No Prescription Order Buy Amoxicillin Online Nexium And Side Effects Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease

Reply

Buy Singulair Vancouver Synthroid Side Effects Weight Loss Increased Appetite

Reply

Zanaflex No Rx Buy Clomid Skin Care Side Effects Of Vitamin C

Reply

Buy Online Cipro 500mg Tramadol Side Effects Prescription

Reply

Buy Ultram Overnight No Rx Online Cardura Xl Side Effects Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia

Reply

Protonix Generic Buy Lamictal And Yeast Infections Side Effects

Reply

Alendronate Online Buy Fosamax Discontinuing Lexapro Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Cilostazol No Prescription Plavix Medications Com Lipitor Side Effects Muscle Pain

Reply

Buy Esomeprazole India Yasmin Bigger Breasts Side Effects

Reply

Pic Buy Xanax Ranitidine Side Effects Acidity

Reply

Mirapex No Prescription Drug Tenormin Atenolol Side Effects Beta Blockers

Reply

6 7 Dihydroxybergamottin And Tramadol Side Effects Of Taking Vitamin C Supplements

Reply

Cvs Cipro Online 20 Mg Side Effects Lisinopril And Hydrochlorothiazide

Reply

Buy Get Online Prescription Cialis Pill Strontium Side Effects Postmenopausal Osteoporosis

Reply

Azithromycin Infiltrate Zithromax Online Metformin Hcl 500 Mg Side Effects Glucophage Xr

Reply

Omeprazole No Prescription There Propecia Sexual Side Effects Androgenetic Alopecia

Reply

Pic Buy Xanax Diabetes Smart Charts John Walsh

Reply

Mirapex Or Requip Drug Side Effects Of Extra Strength Tylenol Counter

Reply

Without A Prescription Buy Clomid Online Xanax Xr Withdrawal Symptoms Drug Information

Reply

Safety Buy Flomax Prednisone Side Effects Short Term Blood

Reply

Wellbutrin Xr No Prescription Lamictal Side Effects Libido Blurred Vision

Reply

Glyburide Glibenclamide No Prescription Femara Mg 5mg 500mg What Are The Side Effects Associated With High Blood Pressure

Reply

Buy Clomid Online Information Muscle Relaxer Side Effects Carisoprodol Soma

Reply

Plavix No Prescription Delivery Sexual Side Effects Trazodone Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors

Reply

Buy Viagra Online Cheap Uk Magic Mushroom Effects Norvasc Prescription Side

Reply

Pak Buy Zithromax Gabapentin Side Effects Headache

Reply

Protonix Generic Buy Side Effect Hyaluronic Acid Injections

Reply

Pic Buy Xanax Lipitor And Nerve Damage Statin Drug Side Effects

Reply

Flomax No Prescription Star Oxycodone Long Term Side Effects Opioids

Reply

Buy Singulair Vancouver What Are Side Effects Of Tetracycline

Reply

Wellbutrin Sr Canada Buying Sexual Side Effects Tramadol Hydrochloride

Reply

Mirapex No Prescription Drug How Does Acai Berry Aid In Side Effects

Reply

200 Tramadol Overnight Fedex Cod Prescription Discount Zocor Side Effects

Reply

Pic Buy Xanax Neurontin Side Effects Hair Loss

Reply

Off Label Buy Singulair Oxycodone Addiction Recovery Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Online Prescription Buy Cheap Fosamax Side Effects Memory Xanax Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Femara Non Prescription Cod Methadone In Drug Testing Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Buy Online Cipro 500mg Simvastatin Side Effects Brand Name

Reply

Wellbutrin Sr Canada Buying Definition Of Considered High Blood Pressure Reading

Reply

Buy Clomid Cvs Without Gabapentin Neurontin Side Effects

Reply

Online Prescription Usa Buy Cheap Amoxicillin Yasmin Saad Avola Coldwell Banker Residential Real Estate

Reply

Buy Cialis Softtabs Online Hydrocodone Information Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Flomax No Prescription Star Nystatin Side Effects Online Prescription

Reply

Buy Clomid Online Information Paying For Methadone Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Clopidogrel Side Effects Cheapest Plavix Online Zoloft Side Effect In Children Social Anxiety Disorder

Reply

Canada No Cost Drug Flomax In Prescription Abilify Side Effects Weight Gain Neuroleptic Malignant Syndrome

Reply

Mirapex Or Requip Drug Coversyl Medication Side Effects Ace

Reply

No Prescription Femara Online Lisinopril Side Effects Nausea Non Steroidal Anti Inflammatory Drugs

Reply

Order Zithromax Online Information Natural Replacement Lexapro Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Flomax No Prescription Guaranteed Ultimate Nutrition Side Effects Bulgarian Tribulus

Reply

Cvs Cipro Online Definition Of The Side Effects Of Bystolic

Reply

Buy Cialis Daily Online Carbidopa And Levodopa Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Buy Esomeprazole India What Could Cause High Blood Pressure Walls

Reply

Protonix No Prescription Anti Acidity Online Walmart Prescriptions Simvastatin Cholesterol Lowering Drug

Reply

Buy Clomid Cvs Without Oxycontin Fibromyalgia Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Cialis Online Prescription Buy Viagra Lasting Side Effects Of Accutane Chapped Lips

Reply

Cheap Prescription Drug Canada Buy Flomax Tamsulosin Tranexamic Acid Indication And Nursing Considerations

Reply

Promo Prescriptions Buy Singulair What Does Tegretol Look Like Side Effects

Reply

Free Wellbutrin Online No Prescription Depression Sexual Side Effects Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors

Reply

Mirapex For Depression Smart Burn Side Effects Hoodia Gordonii

Reply

Buy Viagra Online Cheap Uk Doxazosin Side Effects Online Pharmacy

Reply

Buy Otc Omeprazole Flexeril Carisoprodol Tablets Side Effects

Reply

No Prescription Cheap Order Protonix Hydrea Side Effects Nausea Vomiting Diarrhea

Reply

Finasteride No Prescription Cheap Flomax Walmart And Plan B Planned Parenthood Federation Of America

Reply

Buy Singulair Online Advice Mebeverine No Prescription Side Effects

Reply

All About Tramadol Beautifully Methadone Detox Help Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Acquisition Cipro Online Augmentin 625 Side Effects Diarrhea

Reply

Pak Buy Zithromax Prednisone Missed Dose Side Effects

Reply

Protonix Generic Buy Geodon More Drug_side_effects Healthcare Provider

Reply

Pic Buy Xanax Side Effects Allegra 180 Mg Tablets

Reply

Buy Singulair Online Advice Temazepam And Benadryl Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Another Name For Tramadol Original Lida Daidaihua Ingredients

Reply

Buy Esomeprazole India How Does Cause Death Xanax Withdrawal

Reply

Mylan Alprazolam 2mg Buy Xanax Glucotrol Xl No Prescription Walgreens

Reply

Buy Online Cipro 500mg Weaning Off Prednisone Side Effects Muscle Pain

Reply

Buy Viagra Online Cheap Uk Amlodipine Benazepril Side Effects Cough

Reply

Buy Check Online Prescription Cialis Medication With Weight Loss Side Effects Common

Reply

Buy Esomeprazole India Metformin Side Effects Liver Disease

Reply

Off Label Buy Singulair Ventolin Hfa Walmart Maxair Autohaler

Reply

Mirapex Or Requip Drug Cyclobenzaprine 800 Mg Side Effects

Reply

Rx Buy Femara Online What Are The Side Effects Of Remeron

Reply

Buy Ciprofloxacin Online Uk Mefenamic Acid No Prescription Side Effects

Reply

Cilostazol No Prescription Plavix Rosiglitazone Metformin Side Effects Mg Buy

Reply

Buy Protonix 20mg Methadone Infant Withdrawal Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome

Reply

Mirapex To Requip Conversion Viagra Side Effects For Women Pulmonary Arterial Hypertension

Reply

Fosamax No Prescription Drugstore Blood Pressure Cure Kowalski The Silent Killer

Reply

Order Zithromax Online Information Neurontin Medication Side Effects Slurred Speech

Reply

Buy Ultram Online Cod Fast Side Effects No Prescription Cheap Amoxicillin

Reply

Protonix Generic Buy Tramadol Dependency Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

No Prescription Buy Plavix Mmorpg Acetazolamide No Prescription Side Effects

Reply

Buy Viagra Without Rx Online Pharmacy Valsartan Hydrochlorothiazide Side Effects Cheap

Reply

Buy Ultram With Time A Prescription Walmart Automatic Digital Blood Pressure Monitor

Reply

Esomeprazole No Prescription Overnight Delivery Voltaren Injection Side Effects Toxic Epidermal Necrolysis

Reply

No Prescription Buy Cheap Order Fosamax Generic Cialis Pills No Prescription Walmart Pharmacy

Reply

Femara No Prescription Cost Celebrex Meloxicam Nsaid Free Prescription

Reply

Buy Prescription Order Clomid Online Do Zoloft Side Effects Go Away Anti Depressants

Reply

Buy Viagra Without Rx Online Pharmacy Generic Cialis Pills Side Effects Canada Pharmacy

Reply

Buy Amoxicillin Online Side Effects Sexual Side Effects Of Simvastatin Hmg Coa Reductase

Reply

Flomax No Prescription Guaranteed Herb To Stop Smoking Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Femara Bac No Prescription How Long Does Zoloft Withdrawal Family

Reply

Buy Clomid Cvs Without Tapering Paxil Withdrawal Syndrome

Reply

Buy Viagra Online Read Prescription Metformin Hcl 500 Mg Side Effects Glucophage Xr

Reply

Vicodin Standard Dosage Buy Xanax Vicodin Addiction Pregnancy Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Mirapex Or Requip Drug Buy Lowest Lexapro Side Effects No Prescription Generic

Reply

Cvs Cipro Online Side Effects Zoloft Medication

Reply

Cilostazol No Prescription Plavix Wellbutrin Side Effects Discontinuing Use

Reply

Buy Ultram Overnight No Rx Online Prednisolone Acetate Side Effects Eye Drops

Reply

Pic Buy Xanax Lorcet And Alcohol Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Fosamax No Prescription Drugstore How Long Do Withdrawal Symptoms From Hydrocodone Last

Reply

Cvs Cipro Online How Long Do Lorazepam Side Effects Last

Reply

Buy Viagra Without Rx Online Pharmacy Sexual Side Effects Of Coumadin Pulmonary Embolism

Reply

Pak Buy Zithromax Leslie Sansone 3 Mile Weight Loss Walk Fast

Reply

Flomax No Prescription Star Lipitor Memory Loss Wall Street Journal

Reply

Pak Buy Zithromax Buy Carisoprodol Walmart Prescription Pills

Reply

Buy Singulair Vancouver Suddenly Stopping Lexapro Withdrawal

Reply

No Prescription Buy Cheap Order Fosamax How Long Do Oxycontin Withdrawal Symptoms Family

Reply

Buy Viagra Online And Live Prescription What Are The Side Effects Of Ativan Slurred Speech

Reply

Flomax No Prescription Guaranteed Methadone Regulations Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Wellbutrin Sr Canada Buying Valium Dosage Body Weight Side Effects

Reply

Femara Bac No Prescription Medrol Side Effects During Pregnancy

Reply

Acquisition Cipro Online Vicodin How It Works Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Protonix Generic Buy Apo Amitriptyline Side Effects Elavil

Reply

Finasteride No Prescription Cheap Flomax Sexual Side Effects Trazodone Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors

Reply

Femara No Prescription Cost Blood Pressure Pill Without Side Effects

Reply

Buy Online Cipro 500mg Find Cheapest Celexa Side Effects Nonprescription

Reply

Acquisition Cipro Online Lisinopril Side Effects With Calcium

Reply

Xanax Bar Street Buy Step Out To Fight Diabetes Walk Association’s

Reply

Wellbutrin Sr Canada Buying Migraine Medication Side Effects Naproxen Sodium

Reply

Requip Vs Mirapex Daytime Sleepiness Plan B Bleeding Side Effect Birth Control Pills

Reply

Rx Buy Femara Online Long Term Side Effects Acetaminophen Overdose

Reply

Another Name For Tramadol Blood Pressure Lowering Drugs Side Effects

Reply

Ramipril No Prescription Plavix How Do I Get Oxycontin Prescribed Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Buy Viagra Online Get Prescription Approved Drugs What Are The Side Effects Of Keflex Urinary Tract Infection

Reply

Amoxicillin And Clavulanate Online Consultation Buy What Are The Side Effects Of High Blood Pressure Doctor

Reply

Buy Cialis Softtabs Online Hydrocodone Withdrawal Treatment Severe

Reply

Buy Esomeprazole India Drug Prescription Pravachol Side Effects

Reply

Tolterodine No Prescription Buy Flomax Irreversible Sexual Side Effects Proscar Finasteride

Reply

No Prescription Mirapex 25 Alcohol Interaction Effexor Xr Side Effects

Reply

Alendronate Online Buy Fosamax Methotrexate Side Effects Lymphoma Tumor Lysis Syndrome

Reply

Cvs Cipro Online Taking Too Much Lamictal Side Effects

Reply

Tamsulosin No Prescription Buy Flomax Drug Infant Ranitidine Side Effects Gastroesophageal Reflux

Reply

Wellbutrin No Prescription Our Sr Without Tylenol Sinus Congestion And Pain Side Effects Nasal Decongestant

Reply

Another Name For Tramadol Starter Pack Coupons Alli Weight Loss Aid

Reply

Male Buy Clomid Is Zyprexa Safe Side Effects

Reply

Zithromax Online Liste Urso Forte More Drug_side_effects

Reply

Buy Esomeprazole India Motrin Stomach Irritation Side Effects

Reply

Fosamax Generic Buy Walk For High Blood Pressure Arizona

Reply

Femara No Prescription Cost Side Effects Of Acai Berry Supplement

Reply

Buy Tramadol 00 Buy Norco Online Side Effects

Reply

Plavix Buy Online Risk Of Stroke Amlodipine Besylate Mylan Flatulence Side Effect

Reply

Buy Esomeprazole India Methadone And Alcohol Effects Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Alendronate Online Buy Fosamax Xanax Use In Children Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Promo Prescriptions Buy Singulair Zoloft Side Effects Women Premenstrual Dysphoric Disorder Pmdd

Reply

Online Prescription Buy Cheap Fosamax Cold And Flu Side Effects Children’s Tylenol

Reply

Dose For Kids Buy Zithromax Medrol Side Effects For Herniated Disk

Reply

Mylan Alprazolam 2mg Buy Xanax Swelling Lexapro Withdrawal Side Effects

Reply

Femara Bac No Prescription Acetaminophen Side Effects Oxycodone Hydrochloride

Reply

Buy Clomid Online Hot Flashes Yasmin Negative Side Effects Wondering

Reply

Buy Amoxicillin Online Cheaop Risperdal Recreational Use Side Effects

Reply

Online Pharmacy Cipro Sleep Aids Side Effects Ambien Cr

Reply

Vicodin Standard Dosage Buy Xanax List Of The Withdrawal Symptoms Of Vicodin

Reply

Tolterodine No Prescription Buy Flomax Rivastigimine Side Effects Exelon Power Labs

Reply

Rx Buy Femara Online Diabetes Association Australia New South Wales

Reply

Buy Get Online Prescription Cialis Pill Does Ambien Cause High Blood Pressure Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Zithromax Buy Bacterial Infections How Long Can You Take Prilosec For Side Effects

Reply

Femara No Prescription Buy Cheapest What Are The Side Effects Of Finasteride Hair Loss

Reply

No Prescription Order Buy Amoxicillin Online Zolpidem Ratiopharm 10 Mg Sleeping Pills Side Effects

Reply

Dose For Kids Buy Zithromax Drug Interaction Between Nexium And Rolaids

Reply

Male Buy Clomid Seven Seas Evening Primrose Oil Plus Starflower Oil Swallow

Reply

Cvs Cipro Online Micronor Migraines Side Effects

Reply

Buy Otc Omeprazole Heartburn Sore Throat Difficulty Swallowing

Reply

Buy Singulair No Prescription Tablet Hotel Lamictal Dispersible Side Effects Care Professional

Reply

Wellbutrin No Prescription Our Sr Without Methadone Detox More For_patients Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Buy Online Cipro 500mg Is Runners Or Walking Better For Weight Loss

Reply

No Prescription Cheap Order Protonix Enalapril Hydrochlorothiazide Side Effects Any

Reply

Buy Ultram Overnight No Rx Online Research On Treating Proscar Side Effects

Reply

Xanax Bar Street Buy Clobetasol Side Effects Depression

Reply

Promo Prescriptions Buy Singulair Florinef For Orthostatic Hypotension Side Effects

Reply

Mirapex No Prescription Drug Is Remeron Addictive Withdrawal Symptoms

Reply

Alendronate Online Buy Fosamax Walmart Wrist Blood Pressure Monitor Hem 650

Reply

Azithromycin Infiltrate Zithromax Online Propoxyphene Apap Side Effects Sodium Oxybate

Reply

Pic Buy Xanax Zyrtec Generic Walmart Watery Eyes

Reply

Promo Prescriptions Buy Singulair Price Of Plan B At Walgreens Birth Control Pills

Reply