POSIX IO Must Die!

POSIX IO is becoming a serious impediment to IO performance and scaling. POSIX is one of the standards that enabled portable programs and POSIX IO is the portion of the standard surrounding IO. But as the world of storage evolves with greatly increasing capacities and greatly increasing performance, it is time for POSIX IO to evolve or die.

All of these demands can put a HUGE burden on the file system with the most probable result that the throughput will be greatly reduced while the metadata is queried (don’t forget this is called “high” performance computing, not “mediocre” performance computing so a reduction in throughput is not acceptable).

Imagine a user who runs this command several times a minute. The process is repeated every time because the user wants to know the size of a particular file (or files). Multiply this by several users, and you can see that the load on the metadata can become enormous. If you think that users don’t do this, you would be very surprised to learn that in reality there are hundreds if not thousands of HPC users who precisely do this on a regular basis. In addition, there are application scripts that perform these checks as well.

In my previous career at an HPC storage manufacturer there was a particular customer who became irate beyond all rationality because the results of an “ls -lsa” command did not return the exact size of the file the instant the command was executed. They had scripts that depended upon this command to launch applications and without a precise number at any specific instance their process was stalled. At the same time, they could not tolerate any loss of throughput performance without a further reduction in performance.

Almost all reasonable users can accept that it can take time to return the results of a command but they want accurate information about the state of their files. But there are also users who want the command to return immediately and who also don’t want much (any) reduction in throughput. The compromise that was discussed in the HECEWG was to offer two options to the users. The first option is to give back accurate file information without much reduction in throughput at the expense of taking more time. The second option is sort of a “lazy” metadata update. In this option, the metadata is updated and stored in a cache when the system load “pauses” or the load drops a bit. Then when a user wants file information with this option, the cache is quickly queried and the result is returned to the user. It’s not the most accurate information since it lags the true information by an amount of time, but it has ZERO impact on the storage performance.

If you think this scenario of metadata impacting performance is not likely to happen to you, I suggest you just wait a couple of years or try a small, slow drive in your quad-core system while running several applications. We now have desktops with 4 cores and 6 cores are coming quickly. If all of the cores are used by applications and a good percentage of them are performing IO then you will certainly see some serious stress on your file system. This stress includes both metadata operations and throughput. Not everyone runs a database on their desktop but almost everyone certainly runs a web browser. Take a look at the number and size of the cached files for your browser and I think you will be shocked. The same is true for games. The stress these applications impose on file systems is something not dreamed of several years ago.

So What Happened?

As you are probably aware, the proposed extensions or relaxations have not been approved by the Austin Group. The last update to the HECEWG was four years ago (2006). Why weren’t they accepted? While I don’t know the answer to that question my supposition is that there was not enough of an appetite by enough companies and users to justify the changes. Without companies who are willing to make changes and without enough demand from users there is really no change in the standard. And why should there be? The mighty cruise ship is traveling steadily and people are having a good time. However, history tells us that the HPC world, while smaller than the enterprise world, usually sees problems several years before they happen. Has HECEWG shown that people need more than the POSIX cruise ship can provide to the point where people are going to be forced to jump off the POSIX cruise ship? Given the advances in systems I think they have.

What Next?

While the cruise ship analogy is useful in making a point, the computing world is not coming to an end because the extensions/relaxations were not passed. We are still growing systems beyond 1 PetaFLOPS and storage capacity and throughput are almost doubling every year along with regulatory requirements forcing us to store all data for extended periods of time.

The HPC world is working very hard to keep up with demand. Share storage systems are growing in capacity at an ever increasing rate and throughput requirements are rising as fast as ever. Coupled with the large number of cores in systems all trying to write to the same shared storage and you can easily see the bottleneck developing.

Ideally POSIX should evolve to accommodate the situations in the HPC world anticipating that the same problems are coming to the enterprise world. However this hasn’t happened in four years and shows no signs of happening in the near future.

It may come to the point where new storage interfaces are developed that don’t even use POSIX because the problems have become so severe. There are signs of this happening already. Basically POSIX hasn’t evolved so people are starting to just go around it. This means that the standard is no longer useful and has become an impediment to progress.

Comments on "POSIX IO Must Die!"

What’s up, its nice article on the topic of media print, wwe all be familiar with media is a impressive source of facts.

Stop by my web blog; cheap car insurance in ga

Hi there, I found your blog by the use of Google whilst searching for a comparable subject, your web site got here up,
it seems great. I’ve bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.

Hello there, just was alert to your blog via Google, and found that it’s really informative.
I am gonna wath out for brussels. I will appreciate when you continue this
in future. A lot of folks will probably bee benefited from your
writing. Cheers!

Also visit my homespage – cheap car insurance texas

Stunning quest there. What occurred after?

Good luck!

Here is myy website: cheap car insurance michigan

I have to thank you for the efforts you hafe
put in penning this blog. I really hope to check out the same high-grade content by you later
on as well. In fact, your creative writing abilities has inspired me tto get
my own, personal website now ;)

Here is my homepage – cheap car insurance florida

I every time emailed this website post page to all my associates, as if like to read it then my friends will too.

My page … cheapest car insurance company

I have read sso many content regarding the blogger lovers however this paragraph is truly a good paragraph, keep it up.

Feel free to suf to my page cheap car insurance in michigan

Superb website youu hve here but I was curious about if you knew of any user discussion forums thnat cober the same topis talked about in this article?

I’d really loive to be a part of community where I ccan gget comments from other experienced people that share the same interest.
If you have any recommendations, please llet me know.
Manyy thanks!

Visit my web blog: Cheap Car Insurance

Thank you for some other informative web site. The place else could I am getting that type of information written in suich a perfect way?
I have a project that I am simply now running on,and I’ve been at the look out for such info.

Here is my blog post; very cheap car insurance

Stop by my blog post … Jeremiah

Feel free to surf to my weblog … facebook.sercanbozkurt.com

This paragraph is in fact a pleasant one it assists new the web
people, who are wishing in favor of blogging.

Also visit my page Cheap Car Insurance

It’s really very complicated in this busy life to listen news on TV, so I only use web
for that reason, and obtain the most up-to-date news.

Also visit my homepage – cheap car insurance

Problems with blood clotting and regularly consume garlic is not for those who, even if only as garlic tablets, nausea, vomiting, use the
recommended blood-thinning medication. You will continue to experience all the eulogized features
of Branded Tablet PCs but without the exorbitant prices.
This tablet does not work well with nitrates or alpha-blockers, so avoid
Caverta if you are taking aforementioned medicines.

[url=http://viagraonlineapotheke.com/cialis_generika.html]was ist cialis generika[/url]

In unserer Apotheke kann man Potenzmittel rezeptfrei kaufen und anonym bleiben. Wir stellen Ihnen ein reiches Sortiment an Präparaten und Arzneimitteln, die dabei helfen, den Männern die vergangene Festigkeit und Stärke wiederzubekommen. Mit unseren Präparaten werden Sie sich an die „alten Zeiten“ erinnern und alle Komplexe loswerden. Wir bieten Ihnen Viagra, Levitra, Cialis, Tadalafil, Sildenafil, Vardenafil, Dapoxetin an. Wir sind 24 Stunden am Tag erreichbar und Sie können eine Bestellung jederzeit aufnehmen. Sie können die bestellten Arzneimittel sowie bargeldlos, als auch mit Bargeld bezahlen.

[url=http://viagraonlineapotheke.com/super_kamagra.html]super kamagra[/url]

In unserer Internet-Apotheke kann man Präparate für Potenzsteigerung ohne Rezept kaufen, und zwar dabei anonym bleiben. Wir stellen Ihnen ein reiches Sortiment an Präparaten und Arzneimitteln, die dabei helfen, den Männern die vergangene Festigkeit und Stärke wiederzubekommen. Unsere Mittel helfen Ihnen dabei, sich an „die alten Zeiten“ zu erinnern und sich von den Komplexen zu befreien. Wir bieten Ihnen Viagra, Levitra, Cialis, Tadalafil, Sildenafil, Vardenafil, Dapoxetin an. Wir arbeiten rund um die Uhr und Sie können zu jeder Uhrzeit eine Bestellung aufnehmen. Die Zahlung von den Bestellungen ist in der Regel bargeldlos, aber Sie können auch mit Bargeld bezahlen.

For boosting your chances of gaining you should choose this solution to make sure that you can be in win-win situation. how to get usa targeted facebook likes

Great, thanks for sharing this post.Really thank you! Much obliged.

[url=http://canadianpharcharmyonlineusa.com/]canadian pharcharmy online[/url]
canadian pharcharmy online
http://canadianpharcharmyonlineusa.com/ canadian pharcharmy online

Very quickly this site will be famous among all blogging and site-building visitors, due to it’s pleasant posts

Have you been inclined to get popularity shortly? Online community site Twitter can be the proper way for you. After that, you require to get cheap twitter followers to become recognized to this world. buy followers on twitter

Please visit the sites we stick to, which includes this one, because it represents our picks in the web.

We prefer to honor a lot of other internet internet sites around the web, even if they aren?t linked to us, by linking to them. Beneath are some webpages worth checking out.

Leave a Reply