dcsimg

Google I/O: What to Expect, What to Hope For

The 5 things I hope Google unveils in Android 2.2.

More Than Just a Free Phone?

The folks at Apple have made an art form out of annual conferences with big announcements.

In recent years we’ve seen the iPhone, MacBook Air, and more recently the iPad unveiled to much fanfare.

Not to be outdone by Apple, Google has been making some Waves as well with their annual spring conference dubbed Google I/O.

At last year’s event participants received Android phones with a free month of service, fueling speculation that this year’s attendees may receive some goodies as well.

I confess it would be cool to get a device, even though I already have a few. I already have a Nexus One running Android 2.1 and more or less like it, though I could always give one away or perhaps sell one on eBay — a Palm exec confessed to me last summer, as he happily texted on his Palm Pre.

I guess living in northern California has its benefits — go to a conference, get a phone, hawk it on eBay. Not a bad deal if you can get it! The airfare from Newark would eat into profits, so I’m going to sit this one out.

Or perhaps this year attendees will receive an Android-based set-top box for Google TV? That would be very cool to check out, particularly because the Hollywood video store near my house just closed their doors. Clearly the brick-and-mortar style for media distribution is under some serious pressure. Thank you, Netflix.

Traditional means of selling cell phones is however not yet dead as just this week Google announced that they are closing down their online Nexus One store, instead opting for traditional merchandising avenues for mobile phones — the most likely reason is that we have not yet broken our addiction to subsidized hardware.

I guess they wanted to get that bit of inconvenient news out of the way so Google I/O announcements could dominate the blogosphere this week. Probably a good move — kind of like releasing bad news late on Friday and then commenting on Monday that it is “old news”.

Gear or no gear, this year’s attendees are likely in for a treat, and whether it is a phone or a TV, there is little doubt that the star of the show is Linux based Android.

Android 2.2

Keeping in line with its predecessors, the latest Android release, version 2.2, is code-named after a dessert. This time it is frozen yogurt, or simply “Froyo”. It must be a California thing because folks in Northern New Jersey don’t do frozen yogurt — we have Italian Ices. Remember, we’re the (former) home of the Sopranos.

Keeping with the theme of being part of the “family”, if I were calling the shots in the Android camp, here are a few items I would make sure find their way into Android 2.2.

Some of these items are related to the application and eco-system of Android, not necessarily the OS itself. That said, the more that is “built-in”, the better. So here is my top 5 wish list:

#1 Outlook Synching

I’ve griped about this before and yes, I am still whining about the lack of out-of-the-box Microsoft Exchange support. For those looking to tell me that GMail and Google calendars are enough — they’re not.

Fans of Android want it to gain momentum and getting adopted by corporate users can really aid in that effort.

Of course, the guys at NitroDesk who put out the Touchdown application have to be loving this gaping hole in Android’s ActiveSync capability. It’s raining twenty dollar bills for those guys. Good for them, though all the same, I would have preferred not to contribute after the non-trivial investment in the phone itself.

#2 Enterprise Tools

BlackBerry devices have long been the corporate standard for mobile solutions because of their robust messaging platform and enterprise-class tools. Adding quality remote management features is an opportunity for Android to gain some ground in the lucrative corporate market. The obvious items here are things like remotely provisioning a new device or wiping a lost device. Hardware encryption would be nice also to aid in protecting corporate data.

As attractive as those features would be, there is another feature that BlackBerry users enjoy — something enabled by the BlackBerry Enterprise Server (BES): message distillation.

When an email is sent to a BlackBerry user, it is first picked up by a BES server, pre-processed/distilled/put on slim-fast/etc. and then sent to the device. The net effect is that the recipient just gets the “raw text” of the message and a list of attachments which are individually download-able.

When an email is forwarded from a BlackBerry user, the BES magically sends the original email — complete with the attachments and any text added by the mobile user. Contrast that behavior with an Android user attempting the same “comment and forward” activity — it just isn’t the same.

The other day I read a message on my Android device but didn’t download the attachment. Then I forwarded it to someone on my team, making reference to the attachment. They shot back a note saying “what attachment?”. Unfortunately, the attachment was never sent because it wasn’t first downloaded to my phone.

This is something I would do countless times with my BlackBerry. Part of the appeal of mobile email is that I don’t have to touch the entire message — I just want to read it and either make a quick reply or forward the email to someone else to handle. Having to download a complete message, attachments and all, and then push that entire bucket of bits back up the wireless pipe is costly.

While not a core Android, kernel-level feature, this is an application usage scenario that is important to today’s mobile user. Having to download all of the attachments in order to forward a message is a non-starter. The BES solution saves time, saves battery life, potentially data plan allowances, and in my case, my sanity. Of course, this is larger than just a point release of an operating system, but hey, if Google can spend years developing something like Wave, a better mobile email solution wouldn’t hurt. Enough said, let’s move on.

#3 Tighter Application & Media Browsing Experience

It could certainly be worse, but the Android marketplace needs a face-lift. In particular, it would be nice to browse applications from the desktop. Yes, I know that some of us believe we’re supposed to live on our mobile devices 24/7/365 but the reality is that many of us still spend an unhealthy amount of time at the keyboard of our PC’s, MacBooks, NetBooks, or dare I say, iPads.

Browsing for content: books, applications, music, video, etc. is an important aspect of the entire experience — without content our devices would be fairly boring, rather over-priced phones with under-performing cameras. After all, most of the fun connected to shopping is the “just browsing” experience anyway, right? And no matter how good the browser is on my Nexus One, the browsing is better on my computer, particularly when I consider that my battery isn’t running down and the tabbed-browser experience in Firefox is better than the small screen on the phone.

Again, this is not necessarily a core Android device feature, but rather a user experience issue. No matter how unpopular iTunes may be to some, and no matter how much fun it can be to have distrust of Apple’s business practices, the lack of a core, no-brainer synching solution is a liability for Android. doubleTwist shows some promise in this area, but Google would be making a nice investment in Android if they would put some weight behind this kind of effort. How about even some “Summer of Code” interns to build something in this camp? Please?

#4 VPN and server access

The VPN setup doesn’t allow Group settings — or if it does, they are very well hidden. Cisco owns a significant share of the corporate firewall market and a mobile device that wants to play in the enterprise space would be well served by supporting Cisco products.

A built-in Remote Desktop client would be nice also. Accessing a server in the corporate data center from your mobile phone is a good driver for that market.

There are a number of RDP clients in the Market place — Google should buy one with some loose change and include it with the OS core image.

#5 Stability

OK, so this is perhaps not a “feature”, but I am a bit embarrassed when I have to call someone back because I had to pop the battery due to a “lock-up” of my phone. This is happening to my Nexus One (Android 2.1) about once every other day. I’ve read that it may be due to low memory conditions, but whatever the problem, it is a bit of a non-starter for a TELEPHONE to simply crash when a call comes in!

I suppose I can live with this for now because, well, I paid a lot of money for this thing and I need a real device to finish my Android development book, but I would love it if Froyo can make calls work more consistently. Absurd request, I admit, but that is my reality at present, and unfortunately, I am not alone in this frustration.

I can finally finish the book!

We are in the red zone of completing an update to the Android development book and having lived through many SDK releases during the first edition, I am well accustomed to “running the gauntlet” of trying to find a way through writing the book and hitting the sweet spot of SDK releases.

One way or another, this looks to be a promising week for Android. Hopefully I don’t have to go out there and use my Jersey negotiating skills to get my wishes granted.

Comments on "Google I/O: What to Expect, What to Hope For"

marstein

This year\’s Google IO attendees already received their Verizon Droid phone (or a Nexus if you were not in the US)

Reply
dragonwisard

My droid has never frozen up.

Reply
fableson

@marstein, thanks for the info. I guess they wanted to push out as many iPhones from the ranks as possible before hand! Are you attending?

@dragonwisard: good to hear the droid has been stable for you. The lock ups are very frustrating on the \”flagship phone\”…

Reply
jojoro

Again, trash – complete.
#1 – For MS Outlook exchange wanted (esp. as the #1 item) in the Linux Magazine requests for android features is pathetic.
#2 – enterprise features – If you were using your google apps account or gmail directly, you do not need to download attachments to view unless you want them, and also, they are magically forwarded to anyone you choose. I\’ve enjoyed this feature even on the desktop, since I don\’t have to use a thick client POP/IMAP application to do the same there.

Reply
whitemice

@jojoro

Seriously? You need a reality check,

#1 – You criticize him for wanting to sync his device with a proprietary client on a proprietary platform [at least that is what is assumed since you are implying it is ironic to want that on \"Linux Magazine\"].
#2 – You suggest the solution is to use an ENTIRELY CLOSED AND PROPRIETARY SINGLE VENDOR as the solution.

It thought it was about Open technology, and not Microsoft-bad-Google-good. Either someone believes Open solutions are superior and better protect the user and his investment [in dollars, resources, and data] or one *sells* proprietary solutions. Google is a proprietary solution – and more so that Microsoft. I can at least install my own instance of M$-Exchange and run it for as long as I like. Can you install your own gmail server?

And the \”thick\” IMAP/POP\” client installed by default on Android must be deliberately lame. It is terrible for a 21st century mail client. Install K-9 mail from the marketplace and see that it doesn\’t have to be so – one can have a good \”thick\” [and Open Source!] mail client using standard protocols on the Android.

Reply
dantrevino

@whitemice its about open standards. I\’m not sure the minimal documentation of mapi that was forced by the EU qualifies.

Quite frankly I\’m not sure what \”outlook sync\” means. PST files? Or maybe what the author means is really \”exchange activesync\” (EAS). Or \”exchange calendar sync\”. Or maybe \”exchange scheduling\”.

In any case, is it in Google\’s strategic interest to propagate the status quo? I doubt it. Instead, why not ask Microsoft to open and fully document their protocols?

Personally, I have to use Exchange at work and I\’m not really missing anything thats not already available on the N1. Contacts, mail, and meetings all show up. The only thing missing is the ability to schedule a meeting and browse the GAB for resources and availability. However, I have yet to be in a situation where I\’m urgently needing to book a meeting room from my mobile phone.

I guess if you really really really need to book a meeting room from your phone, or browse the 10000 person global address book, then I can understand the complaint.

Reply
barryp3403

Wow, the one additional thing I would like in Froyo is better bluetooth compatibility.

My Droid works well for me except many bluetooth devices can\’t communicate properly with it. I used to have a Motorola e815 flip phone. I wish my Droid was as good a phone as that was from the bluetooth point of view.

Of course, it is hard to give up a smartphone and go back to a dumbphone but, when driving and finding my in car bluetooth (factory installed 2007 Nissan Maxima) doesn\’t work well when it did with the e815 is a bummer.

Reply
barryp3403

Wow, the one additional thing I would like in Froyo is better bluetooth compatibility.

My Droid works well for me except many bluetooth devices can\’t communicate properly with it. I used to have a Motorola e815 flip phone. I wish my Droid was as good a phone as that was from the bluetooth point of view.

Of course, it is hard to give up a smartphone and go back to a dumbphone but, when driving and finding my in car bluetooth (factory installed 2007 Nissan Maxima) doesn\’t work well when it did with the e815 is a bummer.

Reply
fableson

Thanks for all of your feedback.

I think one of the dangers people can easily fall into is replacing one form of prejudice with another. The open source community is fantastic — awesome stuff has been done and will continue to be done. But we need to be careful to ignore items that have been successful in the marketplace — we do so at our own peril. iPhone has made great strides not only because of the \”app store\”, but also because they have not ignored the enterprise market AND they have made the desktop sync experience basically a no-brainer.

To address specific remarks here:

@jojoro : The world consists of things beyond Google. Sorry if that bothers you.

@whitemice: thanks for weighing in

@dantrevino: I run a small business that has a software package that integrates very tightly with MS Exchange — so leaving Exchange for the near future is not an option; and it is so ubiquitous in the marketplace that ignoring it is foolish. I am often out of the office meeting with people, setting appointments. I need real-time calendar sync. I could live with double-entering contacts, but not calendar. If I cannot immediately schedule something on my mobile device I may as well carry a daytimer notebook. At least I would save the $30 data fee every month that way.

@barryp3403: one bluetooth feature I miss from my BB is the ability to prevent the hands-free device from initiating a call. I have been guilty of \”pocket dialing\” because the button on the hands-free was pressed while in my pocket or backpack since I have moved to the Nexus One.

Frank

Reply
dantrevino

@fableson I\’m not sure why you\’d have to double-enter contacts. Just add your exchange account, select the sync option, and they show up. Google also provides a calendar sync app which will run on you pc.

http://www.google.com/support/calendar/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=89955

granted this is not \’real time\’, nor can you schedule outlook resources, but you can sync both ways (ie add an appointment in gcal and it shows up in outlook), and you can set the sync schedule for as often as you\’d like … like every 1 or 2 minutes.

Or maybe i\’m just misunderstanding your issues.

FYI, CompanionLink also offers an Outlook sync app, but its even more than the Touchdown App.

Reply
fableson

@dantrevino: I don\’t need to double enter contacts — my (unclear!) point was that I value calendar synching FAR above synching contacts. Contacts synching works fine. In fact, I enter most contacts directly on the phone and when they sync to outlook(etc.) the greatest value is when I switch devices. Something I do embarrassingly frequently!

Thanks for the links to the other options — I am aware of them. I often have my laptop with me (though in my backpack, car or hotel room), so that kind of \”leave the computer running all the time\” solution are generally not a good fit for me — and many other mobile oriented folks.

thanks for your input — it adds to the value of this venue.

Frank

Reply

    traflaw dibp&tsn;:j’avoue je surkiffe kidd aussi puis comme tu dis sont new style demonte ;) reste plus que a savoir comment il c fait sa…… mais le perso que j ai le plus hate de revoir c’est marco car pour moi son fruit (le phenix) reste le meilleur de tout les fdd je trouve.

    Reply
taomao

WoW~it is very useful and it adds to the value of this venue.

Reply
linxmax

Well, Google’s I/O was a smart and surprising response to Apple and I think it was for others as well. Whether or not they have beaten the Apple products such as the iOS is yet another story. However, the android app development did leave its mark with the Nexus one and we can be sure that they will hopefully come up with an even better rival for Apple and since Apple gets awake once in a year for the iOS (Possibly June), there is a lot of time for the folks at Google to engineer the I/O!

Reply
samstephan9

It’s really interesting, Thanks for sharing this blog, I will share with my friends too. Thanks
Best Regards, Developer iPhone

Reply

Please write some more on this subject. I really like your website a lot and I honestly think you are a very gifted writer. Cheap Cars

Reply

you really have avery nice blog,it’s the first time to be here but it won’t be the last untill then keep blogging..goodluck!Armenia

Reply

I was very pleased to find this website. I wanted to thanks for your time for this wonderful read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you blog post.

Reply

wyuvnll [url=http://www.chloesutoa.com/]??? ???[/url] cleobkz unpfvzg [url=http://www.chloesutoa.com/]??? ??????[/url] tbnzghh gtortcz [url=http://www.chloesutoa.com/]??? ??????[/url] rxkbrvc ddwaonl http://www.chloesutoa.com/ dxrpdmw ptdmxvw [url=http://www.chloesearch.com/]Chloe ??????[/url] srpniqh yhcmeqz [url=http://www.chloesearch.com/]??? ??????[/url] zhlxeby dvjxibx [url=http://www.chloesearch.com/]Chloe ??????[/url] quoeast wtsntsl http://www.chloesearch.com/ hcsiiuj dsftuzl [url=http://www.chloeonly.com/]??? ???[/url] wouhtgi uyebute [url=http://www.chloeonly.com/]??? ??[/url] rwxnbqg kjaotiq [url=http://www.chloeonly.com/]??? ???[/url] uilpgnp zndwnnu http://www.chloeonly.com/ iekeekv gdrwfbm [url=http://www.paulsmithyasuyi.com/]?????? ??????[/url] dfzwuas femgpqv [url=http://www.paulsmithyasuyi.com/]?????? ???[/url] enuzdqt mklquvi [url=http://www.paulsmithyasuyi.com/]?????? ??????[/url] nwgrxhh atrbcyp http://www.paulsmithyasuyi.com/ oxfqbtw adxygef [url=http://www.pradatome.com/]??? ???[/url] npuobpm pmrhxcp [url=http://www.pradatome.com/]??? ??[/url] rnbtzwy zfyyurp [url=http://www.pradatome.com/]??? ??????[/url] wsjgosp ueeobbp http://www.pradatome.com/ fbkdqwd qbeffum [url=http://www.chloeye.com/]??? ??????[/url] chtajbd sgkshjm [url=http://www.chloeye.com/]??? ??[/url] hslsmfo mcqkdeu [url=http://www.chloeye.com/]??? ??????[/url] fmbsmom qtrjlrf http://www.chloeye.com/ ubsmstq

Reply