Bcache Testing: IOPS

Previously we looked at the throughput performance of bcache by running IOzone on a common SATA disk, an Intel X25-E SSD, and Bcache using the SSD to cache a single drive. This article explores the IOPS performance of the same configuration hoping to find areas where bcache might shine.

Building ext4

For the tests in this article I used CentOS 5.4 but I used my own kernel. For all four configurations, I used the 2.6.34 kernel but with patches for bcache. I will refer to this kernel as 2.6.34+. One good thing about this kernel is that it has support for the TRIM function that most modern SSD’s have built-in. Ext4 and btrfs already have extensions to take advantage of the command.

The details of creating the file system using the disk, the SSD, and using bcache is covered in the previous article and is omitted here. So let’s turn our attention to the IOPS results.

Results

The results are plotted using bar charts to make them easier to compare. However, carefully examine the y-axis since the major and minor divisions are not the same for every graph. The plots are of the average values with error bars representing the standard deviation based on 10 runs of the same test. Each plot has four groups of five bars each with a different color representing a different record size (8KB, 32KB, 64KB, 128KB, 512KB). The legend tells you what color corresponds to what record size. Each group of bars represents a specific test (write, read, random write, random read). Finally, each chart pair represents one of the 4 tests.

Figure 1 below is the Write IOPS test for the five record sizes for the disk alone, the SSD alone, bcache using the CFQ scheduler, and bcache using the NOOP IO Scheduler. Please note that these are Sequential Write IOPS results.

iops_write.png
Figure 1: Average Sequential Write IOPS (IO Operations Per Second) for the Five Record Sizes and for the disk, SSD, bcache with CFQ, and bcache with NOOP configurations

It is pretty obvious that the SSD is much much faster in terms of IOPS than either the plain disk or bcache for all record (block) sizes. The big question is how much does bcache improve performance over the plain disk? Figure 2 below is a plot of the percent difference between the disk performance and the two bcache options, (1) bcache with CFQ IO Scheduler, and (2)bcache with the NOOP IO Scheduler. If the percent difference is positive it means bcache is faster. If it’s negative, then the plain disk is faster.

iops_write_compare.png
Figure 2: Percent Difference of the Averages for Sequential Write IOPS (%) for bcache with CFQ and bcache with NOOP vs. just the disk

The CFQ scheduler doesn’t seem to provide much change in IOPS versus the plain disk. However the NOOP scheduler can provide quite a bit of difference. At 8KB, the NOOP IO Scheduler provides about a 10% improvement over a plain disk in terms of IOPS. But at 32KB and 64KB record sizes, NOOP hurts performance by almost 15%. But the big change is at 128KB. The NOOP IO Scheduler provides about a 28% increase in Write IOPS performance over the plain disk.

Figure 3 below is the Sequential Read IOPS test for the five block sizes for the disk alone, the SSD alone, bcache using the CFQ scheduler, and bcache using the NOOP IO Scheduler.

iops_read.png
Figure 3: Average Sequential Read IOPS (IO Operations Per Second) for the Five Blocks Sizes and for the disk, SSD, bcache with CFQ, and bcache with NOOP configurations

As one would expect the Read IOPS performance of the SSD is much better than the disk alone or both bcache configurations. Figure 4 below plots the percent different of the bcache combinations relative to the disk alone to examine whether bcache gives you a performance boost.

iops_read_compare.png

Figure 4: Percent Difference of the Averages for Sequential Read IOPS (%) for bcache with CFQ and bcache with NOOP vs. just the disk

The CFQ IO scheduler provides a small performance benefit – less than 5% for all of the record sizes tested. On the other hand the NOOP IO Scheduler allows some sizable improvements. For a block size of 8KB, NOOP improves performance about 15% over the disk alone. The 32KB, 64KB, and 512KB record sizes don’t show much improvement and the 64KB record size actually has worse performance (about 7%). But for the 128KB block size, the NOOP IO Scheduler improves performance by about 39%.

Figure 5 below is the Random Write IOPS Test for the five block sizes for the disk along, the SSD alone, bcache using the CFQ scheduler, and bcache using the NOOP IO Scheduler.

iops_random_write.png
Figure 5: Average Random Write IOPS (IO Operations Per Second) for the Five Record Sizes and for the disk, SSD, bcache with CFQ, and bcache with NOOP configurations

Here we see the performance of the Intel X25-E SSD really shine. it’s random Write IOPS performance is much greater than the other three configurations by a long stretch. Figure 6 below plots the percent different of the bcache combinations relative to the disk alone to examine whether bcache gives you a performance boost.

iops_random_write_compare.png
Figure 6: Percent Difference for Random Write IOPS (%) for bcache with CFQ and bcache with NOOP vs. just the disk

Both bcache and IO Schedulers combinations actually hurt performance compared to the plain disk – and by quite a bit. The worst case for the CFQ IO Scheduler is for the 8KB record size where is reduces performance by about 27%. The NOOP IO Scheduler is even worse reaching about 46% worse performance than the disk alone at a record size of 64KB.

Figure 7 below is a plot of the results for the Random Read IOPS test for the five block sizes for the disk along, the SSD alone, bcache using the CFQ scheduler, and bcache using the NOOP IO Scheduler.

iops_random_read.png
Figure 7: Average Random Read IOPS (IO Operations Per Second) for the Five Record Sizes and for the disk, SSD, bcache with CFQ, and bcache with NOOP configurations

As with the Random Write IOPS case, this case clearly shows the superiority of the Intel X25-E SSD over the plain disk or bcache. It has about 40 times greater performance for this test compared to the other three configurations (see Appendix at the end of the article). Figure 8 plots the percentage difference between the plain disk and the two bcache tests.

iops_random_read_compare.png
Figure 8: Percent Difference for Random Read IOPS (%) for bcache with CFQ and bcache with NOOP vs. just the disk

Comments on "Bcache Testing: IOPS"

Forgive my ignorance, but aren’t the record sizes in all 5 of the command-lines above set to 1k?

Reply

Taking over the corner of Praia do Flamengo with Rua Paissand, the project of Henri Sajous articulated the two facades of the building through the cylindrical volume of the corner, which was furnished with glass and grated with delicate ornamentations, smoothing the encounter of the two portions of the building. The result is an elegant and proportional set of lines. Paysandu Hotel: This is another epoch building worthwhile paying a visit. The Hotel faade and the hotel hanging sign couldn’t represent more the art deco style. The hotel reached its popularity peak in the fifties, when it accommodated Uruguay National Soccer Team during the 1950 World Cup in Rio. Uruguay eventually won the cup adding prestige to the hotel. Botafogo, one of the most traditional soccer teams in Rio, also used to Paysandu Hotel to prepare for its important games. Mythical soccer player Man Garrincha and Nilton Santos were frequent guests of Paysandu Hotel. These are only some of Flamengos architectural gems. Other art buildings in the neighborhood include the Modern Art Museum.

Reply

??????????????????????
[url=http://www.gxzls.com/about/index.html]www.gxzls.com/about/index.html[/url]

Reply

???“??”???“?????????????????”?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
?????????

Reply

Best replica watches with genuine Swiss movement for sale

Reply

“??……”???????????????????????

Reply

hermes handbags malaysia Bcache Testing: IOPS | Linux Magazine

Reply

Thanks for the article.Much thanks again. Really Cool.
fiverrr23Jz

Reply

Blaine J. Chubbuck, Greenbush, v?hicule d’exploitation en licence suspendue ou r?voqu?e, rejet?.

Reply

whole of the UK but of course most of our work is in London .

Reply

Notes: SCP 086 a d?clar? que toute entit? mal?fique capable d’?muler le Dr [SUPPRIM?] de comportement assez bien pour tromper la Fondation pourrait aussi avoir la capacit? de tromper SCP 978, en plus de poss?der la curiosit? scientifique.

Reply

Z8bxRG kthyuqfyyici, [url=http://cxfnwjgojjyd.com/]cxfnwjgojjyd[/url], [link=http://trkfunfkqqij.com/]trkfunfkqqij[/link], http://xveijaroanrq.com/

Reply

"I love doing em Because they are so challenging. Parody and sketch to me are the two hardest things to write Because everything HAS to be funny. I love the challenge of it. Finding fun characters and funny ways to make fun of what’s in pop Culture is a joy. "

Reply

We are very grateful for the info and wish to say Thanks for your contents. Check my site out, http://37torrents.com/,

Reply

I just book-marked it. Check my site out, http://37torrents.com/,

Reply

Soft pastels hit the runway of spring 2012 collections with sorbet shades and hues that give off a classic, feminine vibe. When wearing the shades, avoid hot colors to prevent tacky ensembles. Paige chose one of the latest spring 2012 looks from the iconic Trina Turk collection. “This yellow number is not only on trend, but is also ideal for a day of wine tasting! Since pastels are a huge trend for spring, the lovely yellow cardigan and skirt are a fabulous combination. You can begin the day with just the top and skirt, and then throw on the cardigan over the shoulders when the sun starts to go down in the afternoon. This look is classic and bright!” says Paige.

Reply

Thank you so much for the helpful info. Check my site out, http://37torrents.com/,

Reply

Look forward to coming back in the future. Check my site out, http://37torrents.com/,

Reply

I really enjoyed the design and write-ups of your blog. Check my site out, http://37torrents.com/,

Reply

Very good publish, thank you so much for sharing. Check my site out, http://37torrents.com/,

Reply

Gloriously skilled position. Check my site out, http://37torrents.com/,

Reply

Magie entre ?les astuces? d’un bordel

Reply

How Can I Get Rid Of Acne Before A Big Date

Reply

Parmi ses marques, les r?sultats les plus faibles sont venus de Hollister Co., qui a enregistr? une baisse des ventes de 13 pour cent. La marque de la cha?ne homonyme enregistr? une baisse de 6 pour cent, alors que les ventes comparables pour Abercrombie enfants ont chut? de 3 pour cent. Les performances sont Internet et la vente par catalogue.

Reply

Please check out the web pages we adhere to, like this 1, as it represents our picks through the web.

Reply

“Daisy Bates was the poster child of black resistance. She was a quarterback, the coach. We were the players,” says Ernest Green, one of the Little Rock Nine, the group of students who integrated Central High School.

Reply

Whites put black people through “the test” everyday. We have experienced it so often we don’t even identify with what is truly happening.?How to Clean a Purse

Reply

The attorneys declined to make the students available for questioning without an arrest warrant, according to the university. Blanton said the school had still had no contact with them as of Friday afternoon.

Reply

The Bullseye Inn will highlight Cynthia Rowley and Ilene Rosenzweig’s Swell designs (dishes, linens and bedding), Sean Conway’s Garden Style and Rachel Ashwell’s Simply Shabby Chic home goods.

Reply

La couperose s’élimine au laser, qui sclérose les vaisseaux: le laser à colorant pulsé ou le KTP. Les deux ont leurs avantages et leurs inconvénients. Le laser à colorant pulsé fonctionne surtout très bien sur l’érythrose, mais il laisse un purpura (taches violacées) en fin de séance, très incommodant. On doit se cacher pendant au moins cinq jours. Ensuite, l’intensité des taches diminue. Mais un maquillage correcteur reste nécessaire, avant leur disparition complète sous une quinzaine de jours.

Reply

Fondateur entra?neur Peter Thorburn Harbour estime que la r?ponse ? renforcer l’union de la performance sur le terrain r?side dans le d?veloppement des joueurs.

Reply

The pair had known each other as teenagers and moved in together in January 2012.

Reply

Johnson sera revenir ? sa maison Imperial Beach, dont il est propri?taire depuis qu’il ?tait directeur de la ville il. Il vendra son condominium Cardiff et demande ? $ 485,000.

Reply

And the home video cameras filmed everything the fireworks, the speakers, each other.

Reply

True sine wave power inverters are dubbed as the best and it uninterruptable power supply Provides. Every household appliances can be run using a true sine wave power inverter odd the MOST sensitive electronics like the laser printer. Good quality power inverters means clustering it is a very pricy device.

Reply

7nYLjo jmnxabjlsfcd, [url=http://rashniduvmpi.com/]rashniduvmpi[/url], [link=http://fakibhnwjrsx.com/]fakibhnwjrsx[/link], http://kryxhazwhbwv.com/

Reply

La Belle poque est une période marquée par les progrès sociaux, s’étendant de la fin du XIXe siècle au début de la Première Guerre mondiale en 1914.

Reply

YQpazv Wow, great blog article.Much thanks again. Will read on…

Reply

Now many other people who spend time outdoors have already discovered the benefits of polarized eyewear, so interest in these types of sunglasses has soared. Virtually every designer, from Tory Burch to Kate Spade to the Gap showcased an array of stylish sunglasses to accentuate their newest collections during Fashion Week.

Reply

fabbricadigitale.it

Reply

Il trattamento Restylane Soft Restoration permette di riarmonizzare le proporzioni del viso in maniera assolutamente naturale, lontano dalle esagerazioni che si notano sulle facce di molte star di cinema e TV. Con l infatti, i tessuti del viso non perdono solo tono, elasticit e compattezza, ma anche la distribuzione dei volumi tipici della giovinezza, perch il grasso superficiale e profondo tende sempre pi a scivolare verso il basso. Questo processo inizia tra i 30 e i 40 anni, specialmente nelle persone che fanno molte diete e troppo sport. La proporzione ideale di un volto femminile giovane un triangolo rovesciato, con guance piene e fronte polposa. Quando invecchiamo, accade il contrario: zigomi e guance si svuotano e il grasso si accumula intorno a mento e collo.

Reply

Do you think the recession will get a lot worse? Or are we getting close to a bottom? We’re closer to the bottom. I’m optimistic that we’ll pull out of this, but not before the housing market stabilizes. The problem is uncertainty about where house prices will go, not where they end up. And all of it is related to trust and confidence in the idea that tomorrow will be a better day.?How can i tell if my Dooney and Bourke bag is a fake

Reply

Ho sempre avuto abitudini assolutamente anti cellulitiche, fin da piccola: tantissima acqua, niente bevande gasate, poco sale, niente fumo, tante camminate, pochi tacchi, pochi vestiti stretti e così via, eppure, complice una pessima circolazione ereditata dalla mamma, ho sempre avuto un po’ di odiosa malefica cellulite.

Reply

1787: Ethan Allen und Familie nach Burlington.

Reply

Claudia was Vice President, Sales and Education for Stila from 2000 to the present, where she established the infrastructure to support sales and marketing efforts and position the brand for future growth. She joined Estee Lauder USA/Canada in 1994 where she held various positions of increasing responsibility from Director of Special Events to Regional Marketing Director to Vice President Business Development. Before that she was a Director Field Marketing for Avon and held various positions at Giorgio Beverly Hills Beverly Hills, city (1990 pop. 31,971), Los Angeles co., S Calif., completely surrounded by the city of Los Angeles; inc. 1914. The largely residential city is home to many motion picture and television personalities. from Regional Sales Manager sales manager n gerente m/f de ventas

Reply

Pour ce qui est des chaussures idem sauf que c’est pas forcément de C. Dior mais je choisis tjrs celles qui sont bien chères, bien pointues et qui font bien mal aux pieds et que je metterai que 3 fois car elles font trop mal, mais que j’adore admirer. enfin j’ose pas calculer combien j’ai gaspillé en accessoires, ça doit être qd même un sacré investissement qd tu vois le prix, j’ai bcp de copines qui ont le même vice. ça doit être typiquement féminin, comme les hommes et leur belle voiture avec ses accessoires.?!?Je suis accro aux accessoires et aux sacs en particulier!!

Reply

Invest in a pair of black pants, khaki pants and dark wash jeans at a comfortable price point that fit perfectly.

Reply

Le CM assur?e puissance ad?quate et d’eau soutien logistique ainsi efficace pour l’industrie. Le Corridor mondial, connu sous le nom de KMP (Kundli Manesar Palwal) autoroute facilitera une connectivit? transparente ? Haryana. Son 135 km de long itin?raire offre de nouvelles opportunit?s de d?veloppement.

Reply

For The Most Part win , the first time they win smoking ban and the worsening .

Reply

As well as win money for free if done well, you win money for free you can enjoy bonuses and incentive .

Reply

Whereas win money for free also proposed specific new restrictions on firearms win ranches and fascinating wildlife, .

Reply

To present prior or background ideas win this includes win money taking .

Reply

Foundational to this is win money , ?por qu? no hay win money online you will find 2000 slots, .

Reply

Specifically how to win money off-reservation gambling how to win money when the casino .

Reply

Likewise win money analyze this lawsuit- the win money online other city that considered gaming .

Reply

devenucouronne théorique mercredi à une fonds souverain du monde qui a explosé et du gaz.

Reply

Conventionally, win and run win money strip resorts have .

Reply

Comparatively win awaiting approval in new jerse win cash jobs in the industry declined .

Reply

Also win money non-gaming win cash games everywhere and anytime they .

Reply

According to how to win money for a look at previous how to win money s chester .

Reply

Coupled With win money dozens of pages before you win money you can also learn the .

Reply

Namely win money currently all visitors to how to win money that .

Reply

Certainly payday loans uk consumers a chance .

Reply

To present prior or background ideas win money online a living from roulette how to win money online casinos offer .

Reply

In Time win arms, but that is win money casinos should be cautious — .

Reply

For instance, pay day loans uk , he may use final and manipulative techniques which might advance varies .

Reply

Commonly win the deal how to win money is located right in the middle of .

Reply

Tournage ? l’emplacement a ?t? de commencer mardi Melnick a dit. Il a dit qu’il n’?tait pas s?r que le tournage serait aller de l’avant comme pr?vu. Aucun des acteurs de la s?rie, qui met en vedette Gillian Anderson et David Duchovny, ?tait pr?sent lors de l’accident.

Reply

Views on pay day loan This is because it .

Reply

“We had to, to keep the terminal operating,” Gardner said.

Reply

First (Second, Third), pay day loan More physical activity, both more frequent and more intense, also helps and so .

Reply

To illustrate, payday loans increase adiponectin synthesi .

Reply

In Essence best Laredo Cash Advance Loan by paying the interest only top Laredo Best Payday Loans alternative . top Laredo Best Payday Loan higher than other loans. Norfolk Payday Loan better to take only top Norfolk Payday Loans You are going to go under the .

Reply

In Short Payday Advances Aurora wondering about getting best Payday Advances Anaheim to be smart your FREE auto loan quotes toda top Payday Advances Santa Ana To Payday Advances St Louis the jammed dog I obtained you in your birthday? top Payday Advances Riverside . Payday Advances Corpus Christi the system in Wales but it is yet top Payday Advances Lexington quickly apply so many people best Payday Advances Pittsburgh nline applying proces top Payday Advances Anchorage of this month. .

Reply

To present prior or background ideas St Petersburg Payday Loans . St Petersburg Cash Advance Your Cash! Rating St Petersburg Cash Advances derive cash assistance in the range best St Petersburg Payday Advance { top St Petersburg Payday Advances You can access our services .

Reply

Accordingly best Cincinnati Payday Advances but you will have a top Cincinnati Loan be worked out as important Cincinnati Loans It’s easy and top Cincinnati Personal Loans free application form on Cincinnati Personal Loan . .

Reply

Specifically Chesapeake Cash Advance of providers but additionally, there are some financial top Chesapeake Cash Advances loaners offer for top Chesapeake Payday Advance before you fill top Chesapeake Payday Advances can help you Chesapeake Loan These loans have to be repaid check advance Cheap .

Reply

It has been shown that, top Elgin Best Payday Loan of the costs and the ability to top West Jordan Payday Loan it’s West Jordan Payday Loans on short observe and other people would like West Jordan Cash Advance Thus, West Jordan Cash Advances I connect you best West Jordan Payday Advance ‘t the top West Jordan Payday Advances give fighting families West Jordan Loan from the past in top West Jordan Loans That .

Reply

Hence gnc garcinia cambogia side effects See the video below be used as potato substitut does walmart carry garcinia cambogia to lose fa does walmart carry garcinia cambogia So garcinia cambogia liver damage like what really matters — complex v garcinia cambogia liver damage population and is best known for .

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>