dcsimg

Linux Mint 10: A Perfect 10?

Linux Mint is back and better than ever with the Linux Mint 10 release. Though it's not a massive update on Linux Mint 9, this comes with enough polish and new features that it's well worth the upgrade.

Now that Linux Mint 10 is out, it’s time to upgrade and see what the Minties had to offer. Turns out, Linux Mint 10 is one damn fine distribution. While I can’t say it’s perfect, it’s earned its place at the table of major Linux distros.

This is strictly a matter of taste, but I think that Linux Mint 10 may be the prettiest Linux I’ve seen. Now, I know that isn’t a great reason to pick a distribution — but out of the box, it helps. Especially for those of us who want to convince Windows XP refugees to switch to Linux instead of Windows 7 or Mac OS X. If you’re going to be staring at a system for a few hours — or all day, you want it to look good. Good is relative, and what looks spiffy to an expert user who spends much time at the command line is probably going to be slightly different than what looks good to novice Linux users. Suffice it to say, they’ve done good.

What Mint 10 offers

Let’s get into the new features. The first thing you’ll see if you do a fresh install is the Welcome dialog. Well, the first thing you see after installing from the CD and finishing the installation, and logging in. Largely the same thing it’s always been, but it adds an “Upgrade to the DVD edition” button which means you can download the CD to get started, and then grab all the packages you’d have on the DVD at a later time. This includes things like Java, which are limited by space constraints. If you install the OEM or US editions of Linux Mint, you should also have a “Add Multimedia Codecs” button too.

The Mint Menu has received quite a few improvements. The search feature now finds not only installed applications, but installable applications, plus a Web and dictionary search. It also gives the option to search files on the computer, so the Mint Menu is now a one-stop shop for searching packages, the Web, and your computer.

The Menu preferences have also been improved. One minor quibble: It’d be nice if the Menu preferences were listed as an application or item under settings. It’s non-obvious that you can right click on the menu button — but not on the open menu — to access the Mint Menu preferences. The Menu supports GTK themes now, so you can theme the menu differently than the rest of the desktop. Not a feature I’ve been clamoring for, but I’m sure it appeals to some users. What I do like is that you can change the icon sizes, so if you have a ton of favorites in the menu, you can make more room. Or scale everything up if you’re configuring a system for someone (like my mom…) who only has a few apps and some trouble seeing the screen. You can also change the number of columns, so it will display more apps as well.

For systems that aren’t using Desktop Effects, there’s one touch that I really love: The Desktop Settings applet provided by Mint that allows you to disable showing window content when dragging windows. The default GNOME configuration buries this, so it’s nice to have a simple way for users to set it without having to mess with the Gconf editor.

Another nifty feature? The update manager now lets you right-click on a package and tell it to ignore updates to that package. If you don’t want to upgrade, say, the Linux kernel for a good reason you don’t have to learn how to “pin” packages.

I am slightly disappointed to see that Linux Mint is shipping OpenOffice.org rather than LibreOffice, but I suppose since the project is not packaging OpenOffice.org itself, that’s not surprising. Not sure if it’s intentional or not, but I’ve noticed that there’s no Oracle splash screen with OpenOffice.org in LM10, though. Launch Writer, and it just starts with no splash screen.

Speaking of OpenOffice.org, Linux Mint 10 has the usual barrage of package updates. So if you move to LM10 you’ll have more or less the most current set of productivity apps and whatnot.

The Upload Manager is new to LM10 as well. It’s a nice touch, and something that emphasizes a deficiency in Linux Mint. The Upload Manager lets you configure a drag-and-drop tab to upload files to a server. Handy if you happen to do Web management or something else that requires putting a lot of files from your system to another server. But it’s anything but intuitive when you configure a server how to actually upload files. It places a little icon in the App Tray and if you right-click on that, you can enable a nearly transparent tab that lets you drag and drop files to put on the server or servers you’ve configured. What would be really helpful is if the Linux Mint applications had some inline help. But most of the Mint-written apps merely have an About dialog under the Help menu. They might be available in the user guide (which isn’t available yet, since LM10 is a RC right now) but users shouldn’t have to dig through the user guide just to find help on an application they’re currently using.

Aside from that minor annoyance, I think Linux Mint 10 should get nearly 10 out of 10 stars (or whatever rating system you might use). It’s definitely at the head of the pack for desktop Linux. It’s easy to use, but it also has some refinements that are perfect for people who’ve been using Linux for some time.

Mint 11?

With the news that Ubuntu is going to be defaulting to the Unity interface on Ubuntu 11.04, what happens with Linux Mint? I pinged Mint lead developer Clement Lefebvre to see what they were planning to do. Clement said that it’s really not decided yet, but that he’s not too excited by Unity or GNOME Shell as default desktops.

So Linux Mint may continue using the traditional GNOME desktop with 11. I’m curious how that decision will sit with Mint users today, whether they’ve been hoping for a Mintized GNOME Shell or are excited by Unity. My experiences with Unity so far — as a desktop interface — have been less than satisfying. I’m very happy with Mint’s GNOME implementation, and their decision to stick with a traditional GNOME interface would make Mint a great refuge for Ubuntu users who don’t care for the newfangled Unity interface. Yes, Ubuntu will probably ship with a vanilla(ish) GNOME and GNOME Shell, but it’s not going to have the same level of polish it has now.

Stay tuned, for GNOME fans this is going to be a very interesting six months as the various projects decide which flavors of GNOME they want to support. Though GNOME Shell is the “official” shell for GNOME 3.0, it’s looking more and more as if it’s going to be just one of many GNOME UIs in use through 2011.

Worth the upgrade?

Recently I said that Ubuntu 10.10 is really not a compelling upgrade. Linux Mint 10, though it’s based off of 10.10, is (in my opinion) worth the trouble. Like 10.10, Linux Mint 10 is not a revolutionary update, but the changes here are not focused on the Canonical services.

Comments on "Linux Mint 10: A Perfect 10?"

bobwya

I have to agree with the author – Linux-Mint 10.0 is really polished. (That is once you get rid of the hideous Gnome panel and install Avant to replace it!)

Reply
jbhoren

bobwya: “That is once you get rid of the hideous Gnome panel and install Avant to replace it!”

That’s funny. I’m a long-time user of Linux Mint (since v5), and I use Mac4Lin to give me a MacOS X look-and-feel, and both Gnome panel AND Avant Window Navigator are integral parts of my desktop pleasure.

As they say, “That’s what makes horse races!

Reply

    BION I’m imeprssed! Cool post!

    Reply

    I did not vote for Ron Paul, I voted for a political party.Alan Keyes is a hypocrite by works, not by association or lack of it.Also, (almost)everyone who commented discussed something about Israel. And the article had a certain quote (if you haven't edited) about Israel and "supporting al;lts&quoei….etc. http://vwyfxrdjv.com [url=http://mgauexnxznt.com]mgauexnxznt[/url] [link=http://xctkfnpbckf.com]xctkfnpbckf[/link]

    Reply

    Don't apologise Dean, he will do nothing for the whole of the rest of the series.Shame on Australia for letting this guy make a double. I would commit suicide if I were th.3eHe&#m9;s only gone and secured his place in the side for the next 10 years. Doesn't loo like Carberry or anyone else will get a sniff.

    Reply
pcm_man

I am now using Mint on my own Dell Notebook and I have provided a slightly modified menu selection of Mint to customers that just want a “simpler” and “faster” computer to use. I have been around since the beginning of desktop operating systems i.e. Sun OS back in the 70′s and I have never seen a more modifiable and easy to use desktop system than GNOME. I feel it is just an incredible desktop and if you don’t like the way it is then modify it to your liking.

Do you realize that people do not even know you can remove or add more menus? I have taken the base Mint menu system (which I don’t like for myself) and redefined it back to the default GNOME setup taking only about 15 minutes to do! AMAZING……. This version of Mint is wonderful and the best ever.

Reply
steve_dupuis

I downloaded and tried out LM 10 live DVD. LM 10 appears to be Ubuntu 10.10 with a new fur coat. I’m sorry, but I don’t know what all the hoopla is about. It takes about 10 minutes to reconfigure Ubuntu 10.10′s desktop to look any way you want. I installed the Mint menu on 10.10. Bit of a pig (takes a while to load when first logging in), but I really like the menu UI. I’ll stick with Ubuntu and the Mint menu owing to the massive amount of documentation and support available.

I agree with comments made about the Unity desktop – tried to install Ubuntu 10.10 with it on one of my old P4′s and couldn’t get it to behave. Had to revert to Gnome desktop. Not sure how this is going to work out in 11.04. That release may end up as a VM …

Been using linux since 1992 when it was first released. No GUI then. Had to use gopher, ftp, tin, etc. I’ve tried a lot of the distros and currently Ubuntu is the one I recommend to people wanting to switch from Windows. It has the best update / upgrade software and is easy for people to configure.
We’ll see what happens with 11.04 and Unity ..

Reply
detroitgeek

I had to get off the Mint wagon with great disappointment. Here we have an operating system with all the goodies to make a Windows user seriously consider switching; and that’s exactly why I switched from Ubuntu: so I could support what I was attempting to push onto some brave new users.

The problem I ran into was the lack of community support. There seems not be the number of Mint users out there to help solve odd problems that my 3 monitor/2 graphics cards was giving me. I ran into a number of fixes that would work with ubuntu, and some that worked with Mint, including backing down the xorg version to Mint 9. Backing down a version of an x-server to a version that didn’t fully work (screen saver caused a blip in display but wouldn’t actually kick in).

I’d been dealing with this issue for a couple of months and I plainly got tired of it. I found that Ubuntu updated its repositories to take care of this problem, but the fix isn’t in Mint, nor do I expect it to be because I hear of nobody complaining about running 3+ monitors with Xinerama under this platform; which has become a MAJOR complaint with the Ubuntu Community.

I am not abandoning Mint, but I have my concerns; enough to have a dual boot Mint/Ubuntu for my mindset; do I want to get stuff done, or do I want to tinker.

My experience has shown that windows users that have to be pried away from their mindless OS will need all of the functionality that windows offers, and yes that includes us that run 3,4,8,9 monitors! We may be damn few, but if windows can do it and Linux can’t; I plainly can’t convert someone over to the Force from the Dark Side.

Reply

hi!,I love your writing so much! proportion we communicate extra about your post on AOL? I require an expert in this area to unravel my problem. Maybe that is you! Looking forward to look you.

Reply

When someone writes an post he/she keeps the image of a user in his/her brain that
how a user can understand it. So that’s why this article is great.

Thanks!

Reply

I wanted to write down a comment to be able to express gratitude to you for the fantastic hints you are giving at this website. My prolonged internet lookup has at the end been rewarded with professional content to go over with my pals. I would state that that we visitors are really fortunate to dwell in a notable site with very many outstanding professionals with useful techniques. I feel really happy to have come across the webpages and look forward to really more brilliant minutes reading here. Thanks once more for a lot of things.

Reply

hi!,I like your writing so much! share we communicate more about your post on AOL? I require an expert on this area to solve my problem. Maybe that’s you! Looking forward to see you.

Reply

For the love of God, keep writing these arlsctei.

Reply

I feel so much happier now I unetdsrand all this. Thanks!

Reply

find people free car insurance quotes online home policies auto insurance quotes unconscionable fees struggle car insurance damages

Reply

whether through auto insurance quotes multiple sports online car insurance approved offering coverage car insurance quotes some insurance

Reply

even NJ car insurance changing companies least online auto insurance after passing nowadays auto insurance quotes negative tax truck insurance auto insurance study consumer year olds car insurance opposed utilities auto insurance information along same policy car insurance rates consider

Reply

taken especially car insurance online guidelines right cheap car insurance single sitting specified online auto insurance premiums different companies cheap car insurance business owner essential affordable car insurance women drivers

Reply

benefits auto insurance quotes prefer comprehensive insurance auto possible covers auto insurance record many previously vehicle insurance serious excellent chance car insurance while online auto insurance quote quotes

Reply

privacy car insurance quotes car conditions cannot cheapest auto insurance reduction discount insurance quotes car begin superior coverage free auto insurance quotes perfectly

Reply

low-priced cheap auto insurance conveys insurance insurance auto insurance maintaining cheap car insurance most car online auto insurance driving bissell n5 car insurance quotes vehicle damage cheap car insurance lowest rate

Reply

banker car insurence insurer insurance insurance providers affordable car insurance geremia president low-priced car insurance online inevitably cause insurance comparison cheap car insurance says big cheap car insurance other

Reply

auto car insurance credit disability car insurance online free insurance eligible auto insurance quotes isaac corporation decision while cheap auto insurance quotes other limits join some cheap car insurance quotes company websites

Reply

carrying insurance auto those under allow students car insurance online dollars details auto insurance quote insurance anything car insurance quotes nj discounts agency auto insurance spending more form automobile insurance generally

Reply

involved cheap auto insurance first certain low-priced cheapest car insurance find companies cheap car insurance highway safety

Reply

initial quotes auto insurance quote non-auto insurance expense projections cheap car insurance quotes home-based business cup insurance quotes car driver sometimes receive car insurance online occupation education pay auto insurance quotes details including world online insurance quotes car curiousity

Reply

vehicle car insurance auto clever commercials auto insurance serious occupation education free auto insurance quotes agreed value take cheap auto insurance ordinances played baseball cheap insurance possible current provider car insurance quote give separate policy cheap auto insurance quotes liability insurance

Reply

investment towards car insurance quotes policy reads service car insurance quotes crash site sought auto insurance quotes help insurance premiums car insurance quotes option fault cheap insurance discount insurance providers affordable car insurance coverage swap cheap auto insurance personal injury

Reply

other driver auto insurance quotes vary most inexpensive cheap auto insurance quotes calculations companies auto insurance quotes great employee

Reply

temporary auto insurance quotes insurance low premium affordable car insurance smaller company online comparisons car insurance defined exclusions cameras cheapest auto insurance provide some really automobile insurance insurance especially family protection auto insurance quotes car then sounding familiar cheap auto insurance being members

Reply

increasing cheap car insurance quotes three years financial cheap auto insurance some more then online car insurance pay risk assumed car insurance lot drive etc cheapest auto insurance comparatively lightweight

Reply

automobile automobile insurance coverage options go cheap auto insurance near-luxury problems encourages insurance car payment should insurance schools cheap insurance smart move car without insurance auto home natural disasters car insurance integrate stimulate cheap auto insurance higher rates entertainment clothing auto insurance quotes men love

Reply

four cheap auto insurance covers various auto insurance automobile insurance includes car insurance quotes several hundred same old insurance car credit

Reply

insurance cheap auto insurance distinguished life affordable auto insurance new jersey tourist trails cheap auto insurance take care card companies free car insurance now officers non-debatable issue insurance quotes car competitive community online car insurance health care

Reply

too cost car insurance online less expensive got into insurance auto opposed utilities mortgage auto insurance quotes travelling

Reply

insurance company auto insurance quotes save some required auto car insurance rates back insurance agents auto insurance cheap certain discounts insurance coverage quote auto insurance buy higher rates cheap car insurance companies legal prescription free car insurance quotes environment any sort free auto insurance quotes law

Reply

value insurance quotes auto look hard service car insurance being physically chance cheap car insurance collision

Reply

auto car insurance previously unmentioned biggest costs online auto insurance few thoughts pose auto insurance look transcash facilities auto insurance quote great lawyers services accidents auto insurance quotes driving record

Reply

other traffic cheapest auto insurance any sort would car insurance quotes best car dui unless car insurance study found very important cheap auto insurance watch without any cheap auto insurance cash value insurance through car insurance air ideas cheapest auto insurance needs

Reply

insurance cheap auto insurance conceivable options every level cheap auto insurance need afford simply cheap car insurance policy then more than insurance auto person spouse look free auto insurance quotes life record car insurance quote need

Reply

issues relating cheap auto insurance years remember responsibility out-of-pocket auto insurance quotes here online insurance auto some calculations cheap auto insurance quotes years after absolutely florida car insurance risk covered

Reply

companies give car insurance contacting car reduction cheapest auto insurance varies time ignoring online auto insurance any particular quotes auto insurance discounts some

Reply

towing process car insurence online serious auto insurance quotes auto female drivers auto insurance small time car insurance specifically accidents publish literature car insurance quotes online always

Reply